Reservation
+1 239-337-2625
Visit Us
2225 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901, United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Medium 12" Custom Pizza
Lemon Berry Cake
Vegetariano Pizza
Personal 9" Custom Pizza
About
Capone's Coal Fired Pizza
Welcome to Capone's Coal Fired Pizza, a hidden gem located in the heart of Fort Myers, FL. Nestled at 2225 First St, this restaurant perfectly marries a unique gangster theme with a warm and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, stopping by Capone's is a must for anyone craving a slice of pizza perfection.
Capone's specialized coal-fired pizzas are crafted with love, featuring a delightful blend of fresh ingredients and an array of toppings. The Medium 12" Custom Pizza is particularly popular, adorned with tangy tomato sauce, bubbling mozzarella, exquisite Romano cheese, and a topping of your choice for just $17.64. This pie boasts a thin, crispy crust with an almost smoky flavor, a hallmark of its unique cooking method.
But the menu doesn’t stop at pizza. The Cajun Chicken and Shrimp Linguini is another highlight, showcasing housemade linguini tossed with tender shrimp and chicken, all enveloped in a rich Cajun cream sauce that’s bursting with flavor. Priced at $25.88, the dish is a perfect example of how Capone's elevates traditional Italian recipes to new heights.
The atmosphere is bustling yet cozy, reminiscent of classic mobster films. Many patrons have commented on the restaurant's vibe, noting how it transforms a casual meal into an experience. As one customer shared, "The decor and theme was very cool and unique," reflecting the ambiance that's both engaging and memorable.
Choosing to dine here is also an experience that brings the community together. With consistently exceptional service, whether you're dining in or ordering takeout, guests rave about the attentiveness of the staff. One diner mentioned, "The host is very nice," highlighting that personable touch that Capone's provides even during the busiest times.
For those with a heartier appetite, the Capone’s BIG Stuffed Pies are not to be missed. With offerings like the Caprese Stuffed Pie—a hand-tossed delicacy oozing with cheese, chicken, and fresh mozzarella—this pie is not just a meal; it’s an experience priced at $28.24. This is where tradition and creativity collide, ensuring that every bite is genuinely satisfying.
In summary, Capone's Coal Fired Pizza stands out in Fort Myers for its vibrant atmosphere, exceptional dishes, and a commitment to quality that keeps customers coming back. Whether you choose a classic pizza or explore their pasta offerings, each plate promises to deliver a slice of culinary joy. Visit them today and taste for yourself why this local gem has earned a loyal following.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Really cool atmosphere, especially if you like the mob/gangster thing. We happened to go on a Friday when downtown host the Music Walk. It was very busy but service was still great. The apps, pizza, and desserts were fantastic. We had been here a few years ago, and would definitely return again when in the area! ”
“ I would definitely recommend this restaurant. I sometimes only come to this area to eat here because it’s very good. The atmosphere for dine-in lunch and dinner feels welcoming and the light are a bit dim. I’ve called for to go orders and I’ve never had problems with time or getting the wrong food. To add, the host is very nice and she also speaks spanish but I don’t remember her name. The pasta does not make you feel heavy after eating and the pizza has a great thin crust with fresh simple ingredients, the tomato sauce is delightful. I can see why it can get busy. Try the Chicken Alfredo pasta that’s light but creamy, the Cajun chicken shrimp linguine that has spicy kick to it, and the Chicken Pesto Sandwich with the tortellini salad. :) ”
“ Love this place. Always accommodating no matter how many we pop in with for a meal, this time it was 18. Do wish they would take reservations but they are great for placing us. Food and service was excellent as always. ”
“ Lunch special was spectacular. Angel was our server, he suggested the fresh pasta. Chicken and mozzeralla over fresh linguini. Chicken seasoned perfectly, pasta was soft, and tomato sauce was a little watery but had amazing flavor. Was a quiet day downtown but this restaurant was bustling. Will be back! ”
“ We ordered a 12” pepperoni and a 14” “Tommy gun” pizza. The atmosphere was awesome, the decor and theme was very cool and unique. The service was also very well. And for the pizza being made and cooked right there for you to see, the wait time wasn’t long either. Would definitely eat here often and bring friends if I lived in the area. ”
“ We had a great dinner at this restaurant in July! We turned up spontaneously without a reservation, but luckily there were a few tables outside. Inside it was full. But we were really happy with our table outside. The waitress could have been a bit more outgoing and friendly though but it was fine. I ordered the vegetarian pizza with vegan cheese and it was really tasty. Everything was fresh and it is really great that they have vegan cheese. My mum had the Mediterranean salad and it was really good too. The portion was big too, which was great. My sister had the chicken pesto panini and she can recommend it as well. I had never had a pizza served on an etagere before, but it was really fun and different, which I liked. I would also like to mention that they refilled our lemonade for free which I is really nice, especially in the hot Florida weather. ”
“ Fun must see place for Italian pasta pizza fans. Cool place to check out the door handles to enter our machine guns and be sure to check out the glass floor where you'll see the safe and a few other surprises. Lots of great pics on the walls that really fit the theme and the food was really good. There were eight of us and we had great service and assortment of dishes I had the panini and it was fantastic. ”
“ I love the history of Al Capone presented here in a unique way. I recommend the pizza as it is the best. The servers are very friendly. Nice restaurant for the family to enjoy. The drinks are very refreshing. ”